Bohm’s Alarming Decline
Alec Bohm, the Philadelphia Phillies’ once-promising third baseman, has suffered a catastrophic regression in 2025. After a stellar 2024 season that solidified his status as a cornerstone, Bohm is now slashing a dismal .222/.252/.274 with zero home runs, a negative WAR, and 22 strikeouts through early May.
His inability to get on base, coupled with a penchant for grounding into double plays, has turned him into a liability for a team with championship aspirations .
Missed Opportunity: The Nolan Arenado Factor
Last offseason, the Phillies passed on a chance to acquire future Hall of Famer Nolan Arenado from the Cardinals—despite Arenado waiving his no-trade clause specifically for Philadelphia. The front office’s faith in Bohm as their long-term third baseman now appears misguided.
Arenado, a perennial Gold Glover and power hitter, represented a proven upgrade for a team that has fizzled in the playoffs two years running. With St. Louis potentially reopening trade talks, the Phillies’ hesitation looms larger than ever .
Trade Scenarios: High Risk, Higher Stakes
Philadelphia faces limited options to salvage Bohm’s value:
1. Package for Arenado & Helsley: Bohm could anchor a deal for Arenado and elite closer Ryan Helsley, addressing two critical needs.
2. Swap for Luis Robert Jr.: Bohm’s talent (evident in 2024) might entice the White Sox to part with Robert, a high-ceiling outfielder whose 2025 struggles mirror Bohm’s.
3. Sell Low or Hold: If traded now, Bohm’s value is at rock bottom—but retaining him risks further undermining a win-now roster .
The Bigger Picture: Phillies’ Championship
WindowPhiladelphia’s core—Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Zack Wheeler—is built to contend immediately. Bohm’s collapse exacerbates existing holes in power hitting and late-inning relief. As the Phillies languish in the NL East, front-office inertia could waste a prime title window.
Tough decisions loom: double down on Bohm’s potential or aggressively pursue proven talent .
Bohm’s Regression: 2024 vs. 2025
| Stat | 2024 Season | 2025 Season (Through May) |
|——————-|———|
| Batting Avg | .290 | .222 |
| On-Base AVg| .365. | .252 |
| Slugging % | .480 | .274 |
| Home Runs | 20 | 0 |
| WAR | 3.9. | Negative |
Why This Matters
The Phillies’ 2025 stagnation isn’t solely on Bohm—but his fall from All-Star to sub-replacement-level player symbolizes a broader failure to maximize a championship-caliber core. With trade deadlines approaching and rivals surging, Philadelphia must choose: loyalty to a fading asset or a bold move to reignite their October hopes .
