In rugby league, reputation can often run ahead of reality. A player doesn’t have to be bad to be considered overrated – rather, they may simply receive more praise, attention, or credit than their performances consistently warrant.
Using that lens, and keeping in mind the Cambridge Dictionary definition of “overrated” as someone considered better or more important than they truly are, here is a club-by-club breakdown across the NRL.
Brisbane Broncos
If this list was written before the finals, Reece Walsh would have been the obvious selection. However, given his decisive role in delivering a premiership, that tag now feels harsh. Instead, Adam Reynolds emerges as the pick. While an excellent leader, Brisbane’s unbeaten run during his injury absence, combined with middling try-assist numbers for a halfback of his standing, suggests his on-field impact may be overstated.
Canberra Raiders
Joseph Tapine’s influence is undeniable, but at times his reputation outweighs his week-to-week dominance. He remains a strong performer, though not always the game-breaking force he is made out to be.
Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs
Matt Burton’s booming boot and highlight moments have earned him plaudits, yet his consistency in controlling games has fluctuated. The hype around him hasn’t always aligned with his overall contribution.
Cronulla Sharks
Nicho Hynes is one of the most debated names in the league. While capable of brilliance, his struggles in high-pressure matches have raised questions about whether his elite status is fully justified.
Gold Coast Titans
David Fifita’s raw power is unmatched, but his tendency to drift in and out of contests means his reputation as a dominant forward doesn’t always translate across 80 minutes.
Manly Sea Eagles
Tom Trbojevic, when fit, is exceptional. However, ongoing injury concerns and inconsistent availability have made his reputation slightly greater than his recent output.
Melbourne Storm
Cameron Munster remains a match-winner, but his form swings have led some to believe his influence is occasionally overstated compared to Storm greats of the past.
New Zealand Warriors
Roger Tuivasa-Sheck’s leadership is invaluable, yet his attacking impact since returning to rugby league hasn’t always matched the acclaim.
Newcastle Knights
Kalyn Ponga’s talent is unquestioned, but injuries and defensive lapses mean his superstar label often outpaces his consistency.
North Queensland Cowboys
Valentine Holmes’ versatility is praised, though his impact can be patchy across seasons.
Parramatta Eels
Dylan Brown’s potential is immense, but the expectation that he single-handedly transforms the Eels has sometimes exceeded reality.
Penrith Panthers
Liam Martin’s presence is crucial, though critics argue his influence is more subtle than his reputation suggests.
South Sydney Rabbitohs
Latrell Mitchell’s talent is obvious, but ongoing debate surrounds whether his performances consistently justify his superstar billing.
St George Illawarra Dragons
Ben Hunt carries the Dragons, yet his reputation can overshadow quieter stretches in form.
Sydney Roosters
James Tedesco remains elite, but signs of decline have sparked debate about whether his status still matches his output.
The Dolphins
Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow’s speed excites fans, though his overall game continues to develop.
Wests Tigers
Jarome Luai’s brilliance is clear, but operating behind a struggling pack has limited his ability to fully justify the hype.
As always, this list is subjective. Overrated does not mean untalented – it simply reflects the gap between perception and performance in a league where expectations are sky-high.
